There are three main types of adoption in the US (excluding relative & step-child adoption, that is).
There’s fost-adopt, where children taken into foster care are placed with a family, in the hope that, if they can’t be reunited with their birth family, their foster family will be the ones to adopt them. There’s international adoption, where usually toddlers & occationally older children are adopted and brought into the US. Then there’s independent, domestic adoption, where the birth mother or family choose who will raise their baby (occationally it’s a slightly older child, but usually it’s a baby), then the adopting family arrange the adoption through the courts using an attorney.
We liked the sound of all three types of adoption, and would have had a hard time choosing between them. Though, we hate the idea of ‘rescuing’ a child; if we’d adopted from foster care or from another country, yes, we’d probably be giving that child a better upbringing than they might otherwise have had, but that’s not why we’d be adopting them. We’d be adopting them so they became a member of our family, so that we could become their parents. Not through any misguided idea of ’saving’ a child.
However, it turns out we don’t have a lot of choice in this. Since we don’t have our green cards yet, we can’t adopt from foster care. We also can’t adopt from abroad, as we wouldn’t be able to get a visa to bring a child into the country, unless they’d already lived with us for two years.
Which leaves us with just independent, domestic adoption. This isn’t second, or third, best though. We really would have had trouble deciding which route to take if they’d all been open to us. Well, now the decision is made for us, it lets us concentrate on the best aspects of this route - we get to be chosen by our baby’s birth family. They decide that we’re the ones they want raising their child. We also get to have an ongoing relationship with them. Even if that’s just a letter and photos once a year, it’s got to be better for the child to have some info on their birth family.
We’d like it to be more than that though; ideally our child would get to meet their birth family. Grow up knowing who they are, getting to play with cousins, getting hugs from their birth grandparents, getting to see who they look like, who’s mannerisms they have. Ideally, their birth family will be part of our extended family.